Circular debt and why you should go solar

Ahmed Alam 04:21 PM | 20 Aug, 2021
Circular debt and why you should go solar

Circular debt in the energy sector is the monster that isn’t particularly highlighted in the media. I'll try to give a brief overview of how the energy sector currently works in Pakistan. 

The power sector in Pakistan includes both private and state-owned enterprises. Currently, almost 58 percent of the total installed capacity is in the private sector IPPs (independent power producers) and the rest is in the public sector. At least 61 percent of the electricity generation is contributed by the private sector. The only exception is Karachi where both transmission and distribution are controlled by K-Electric. 

In the distribution sector, about 90 percent off net consumers are served by state owned enterprises. Every government fails to transform the energy sector structurally and tries to “fix it” through short-term measures (increasing consumer power tariffs and liquidity injections). Direct and indirect stimulus of Rs7.86 trillion has been thrown into the energy sector since 2006 to save the system from collapsing, but in vain. 

In Pakistan, a lack of cost-effective planning led to direct negotiations with the IPPs. The policy of taking or paying contracts with sovereign guarantees provided by the state has brewed up financial problems for the power sector. The guarantees clauses in power purchase agreements (PPAs) with these IPPs have saddled the government with hefty liabilities. 

The same policy is still in effect and it dates back to 1994. These polices have led to an expensive fuel mix. IPPs must be paid in USD thus diluting our precious forex reserves. Guaranteed capacity payments have massively distorted the cost structure of electricity generation in Pakistan. 

As in June 2018, contracts were made with the CPPA for a generation capacity of 42,349MW against the maximum billed demand of 28,687MW. Despite not using this surplus of 13600MW, Pakistani taxpayers are on the hook for dues. Look into the energy sector further, you’ll find that our reliance on foreign inputs for the energy sector is increasing. I could write on, but I think I’ve set the narrative. Anyone wanting to look into the energy sector further could read the Profit magazine and the terrific research paper published by PIDE. 

In summary, electricity prices in Pakistan will keep increasing for consumers. But don’t lose hope because projects like Dassu Hydropower Project and the bilateral gas pipeline project with Russia can act as light at the end of the tunnel.

Let’s start with the simple aspects of this proposal. The efficiency of this setup may vary place to place due to general weather, type of residence and other minuscule reasons. Take into perspective, Karachi has a clear weather the year round (about two weeks of rain and cloudy days) while you can’t say that for Islamabad. Can you? Keeping in mind our climate, generating solar energy may prove to be the most efficient, cost effective and reliable source of renewable energy.  

Types of Solar System Setups:

On-Grid Solar System: 

As per sales data, this system has been adopted by industrial and retail consumers alike. The national grid acts as a “virtual” battery and does not require physical batteries to store surplus energy. Net metering takes account of the units supplied to the grid so the owner can get free units or cash against it. Though this system does not provide any backup in case of loadshedding. 

Off-Grid Solar System:

This system is used in cases where access to the national grid isn’t possible. It is also comparatively more expensive as physical batteries are required for this setup. Any surplus is stored in the batteries. This setup does not offer the net metering option and seems fit only for operations in remote places.

Hybrid Solar System:

As per sales data, this system has been most preferred by the commercial sector. This system provides both options for net metering and battery backup as well. The owner can sell excess electricity back to the grid and get backup in case of an outage. The downside is that this system has the most expensive set-up. 

Mapping Viability of Setup:

The reader of this article is most likely a household retail consumer of electricity. I’ll assume that this person is living in a two-storey house with six household members and ample space for such a setup. A 10KW set-up in this case seems appropriate according to electricity consumption pattern for such a household. 

My personal advice would be to choose the On-Grid solar system setup. Why so? Just take a glimpse at those numbers. The cost of this setup is around Rs1.15 million but with a projected income of Rs2.7 to Rs3 million per annum you can capitalise on an ROI of 20 percent at the minimum. That’s not even the best part. Because of the viability of this setup, a loan could be obtained at minimal rates of around six percent. 

So, your average consumer would pay less in installments than he would be paying for his average monthly electricity bills from the start. Bonus, this would shield the consumer from future inflation. I predict that energy price increase will be above the core CPI (consumer-price index) inflation. As mentioned above, there is a need for foreign inputs like coal, furnace oil, and LNG. Coal is at all time high ($140-$150). 

Oil is above $70 (to remain above this base price for the year according to market analysts), and LNG rose to record highs as well. I’m pretty sure that inflation tax is due. In short, beneficiaries will net an ever-increasing ROI in both nominal and real terms if my rightful prediction follows suit.

Ahmed Alam
Ahmed Alam

An avid reader of books penned by the likes of notably Benjamin Graham, Jim roger, Ray Dalio and many other, the author is a university student pursuing a combined bachelor’s in Economics and Mathematics. He has a deep ...


KARACHI - Following are the foreign currency exchange rates for US Dollar, Saudi Riyal, UK Pound Sterling, U.A.E. Dirham, European Euro, and other foreign currencies in Pakistan open market on February 7, 2022 (Tuesday).

Source: Forex Association of Pakistan. (last update 09:00 AM)

Currency Symbol Buying Selling
US Dollar ‎USD 274.94 275.69
Euro EUR 296.66 297.26
UK Pound Sterling GBP 331.71 332.41
U.A.E Dirham AED 74.8 75.1
Saudi Riyal SAR 73.21 73.51
Australian Dollar AUD 190.31 192.72
Bahrain Dinar BHD 732.23 740.23
Canadian Dollar CAD 205.22 207.42
China Yuan CNY 40.72 41.12
Danish Krone DKK 39.92 40.32
Hong Kong Dollar HKD 35.08 35.43
Indian Rupee INR 3.35 3.46
Japanese Yen JPY 2.5 2.54
Kuwaiti Dinar KWD 900.32 909.32
Malaysian Ringgit MYR 64.65 65.25
New Zealand Dollar NZD 174.19 176.19
Norwegians Krone NOK 27.12 27.42
Omani Riyal OMR 715.11 723.11
Qatari Riyal ‎QAR 75.64 76.34
Singapore Dollar SGD 208.03 210.03
Swedish Korona SEK 26.1 26.4
Swiss Franc CHF 297.31 299.81
Thai Bhat THB 8.25 8.4

KARACHI – The price of a single tola of 24-karat gold in Pakistan is Rs 202,200 on Tuesday. The price of 10 grams of 24k gold was recorded at Rs173,360.

Likewise, 10 grams of 22k gold were being traded for Rs167,318 while a single tola of 22-karat gold was being sold at Rs 195,157.

Note: The gold rate in Pakistan is fluctuating according to the international market so the price is never been fixed. The below rates are provided by local gold markets and Sarafa Markets of different cities.

City Gold Silver
Lahore PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Karachi PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Islamabad PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Peshawar PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Quetta PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Sialkot PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Attock PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Gujranwala PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Jehlum PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Multan PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Bahawalpur PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Gujrat PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Nawabshah PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Chakwal PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Hyderabad PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Nowshehra PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Sargodha PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Faisalabad PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350
Mirpur PKR 202,200 PKR 2,350


Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter

Sign up for Newsletter